By Knut Engelmann:
2015 has been a good year for IPOs in Germany – not since 2007 have so many companies sought to go to market at the Frankfurt Stock Exchange as they have since the start of the year. New shares worth more than EUR 7 bn were sold across 16 initial offerings, a remarkable resurgence in deal activity from the post-crisis hiatus.
But that is not to say that 2015 was an easy year for those working in equity capital markets. In fact, 2015 was tough year marked by extreme volatility in global markets that forced a handful of IPOs to be postponed or shelved at the eleventh hour. Had it not been for these last minutes postponements, 2015 would likely have set a new record for IPO volumes in Germany.
The postponements came about for a number of reasons, including concerns of a protracted economic slowdown in China and rising U.S. interest rates, which unnerved investors and drove market volatility to new heights.
Volatility, as measured by the VIX Index of volatility, rocketed to above 40 in late August, a level not seen since late 2011, after trading at under 20 for most of the year. Most bankers would likely have told clients six months prior that IPOs simply cannot be successfully completed at volatility levels much above 20, given the direct impact this uncertainty has on investors’ risk appetite. Yet, two of the year’s biggest German deals, Covestro and Scout 24, both supported by CNC, enjoyed successful market debuts at volatility levels around or just over 20, respectively.
This was uncharted territory for companies, their bankers and their communications advisors. Understanding why some flotations succeeded against this difficult set of market conditions, while others floundered, is something that we at CNC have sought to better understand since.
Our analysis leads us to conclude that three ingredients proved critical in the successful flotations: flexibility; a convincing and well-told equity story; and delivery by a strong and confident management team.
Firstly, flexibility. Several IPOs had to be restructured amid tough market conditions, resulting in lower volumes and/or reduced offer prices. One of the most successful IPOs of the year, online real estate and autos platform Scout24, came with an innovative “upsize option”: it would have allowed the company to increase its IPO volume and change the price range at which it was selling its shares after the official prospectus had been released – a legal novelty in Germany but a mechanism not uncommon in U.S. markets. Coupled with a robust business model, stable cash flows and the support of a well-told equity story, Scout24’s shares flew off the shelves.
The second ingredient that proved critical in ensuring IPOs were successful in these volatile conditions was the ability to sell a strong narrative – in essence, good story-telling. Compelling equity stories were the hallmark of each of the successful IPOs this year – whether it was Covestro, which managed to sell EUR 1.5 bn worth of new shares despite having to cut the deal size at the last minute, or Siltronic, also supported by CNC, which was spun off from Wacker Chemie and achieved a total volume of EUR 380 mn More than ever, the tough markets of 2015 put the spotlight on the quality and sustainability of an IPO candidate’s equity story.
The third element of success was the need for a strong and credible management team. A good story requires an equally good story teller to get it across to an audience that needs convincing. The tough markets of 2015 served to highlight the importance of the CEO and the CFO in selling and telling a company’s equity story. As CNC detailed in its exclusive survey of 500 investors published in 2014, the credibility of a company’s management is the second most important factor – after corporate strategy – that investors scrutinise when judging a company and its potential. Strong teams such as those at the helm of Covestro, or the team in charge at Scout24, clearly heeded this advice. And they made a lasting impression that ensured success in the aftermarket: Covestro’s shares, for example, have risen by more than 30% since their market debut.
In fact, it is a stock’s post-IPO performance that is the final determinant of the success or failure of any new offering.
IPO candidates need to remember that they are in for the long game. That means not only believing in the story and its potential, but at a practical level setting up the necessary structures required to communicate the story for the foreseeable future. Any newly listed company will find itself at the centre of a plethora of new regulation and increased transparency requirements from both the markets and the media.
Those that fail to prepare sufficiently for this increased level of publicity and scrutiny risk damaging both their performance and their credibility. It pays to prepare for life in the limelight of the global market – well before it is switched on.