By Jochen Legwie:
“Japan is different.” We often hear this claim – particularly from foreigners struggling with this country, and foreign firms failing to succeed here.
“The media works differently in Japan.” This claim is also often heard. And it is actually correct. At least, it was – until recently. But we are now witnessing changes that are bringing Nippon closer in line with international standards and customs. And that will have profound implications outside Japan, too.
Japan’s most noticeable media feature is probably its infamous press club system. There are about 800 press clubs nationwide, which set the tone on coverage of political, economic or societal issues.
The big wires, dailies and TV stations are in, while other media – magazines, online media, freelancers and most international media – are not. Domestic issues dominate. As a result, foreign companies have less interaction with local media in Japan than they do elsewhere. Likewise, Japanese companies interact less with foreign media.
That’s down to history, and geography: Japan is an island state. And being an island state with a huge economy, there was little need to adapt to international rules and standards for communication. But this is changing in a globalizing economy, as more and more Japanese companies venture abroad for the growth that can’t be found in their stagnating domestic market.
So what is changing in terms of PR and media for international companies in Japan? Actually, a lot – but three trends are worth mentioning in particular.
First, the clout of international media is rising – especially the likes of Bloomberg and Reuters. For the first time in history, the Japanese government actively reaches out to international wires and newspapers to help it shape global opinion. We see more and more background briefings and exclusive interviews granted to such global media, as opposed to the usual suspects like the Yomiuri or Nikkei newspapers. Last year, Prime Minister Abe even spent four hours of his US trip at a Bloomberg event, including pre-day on-site rehearsal and an extended discussion following his speech.
Second, Japanese companies are starting to discover the power of strategic communications. Some of them, like Nissan, Takeda and Lixil, have even installed foreigners as Chief Communication Officers. This is a radical departure from past practice – usually the Head of PR was a former HR or General Affairs manager with little PR experience and no direct line into the CEO, reporting instead to the Head of Strategy, Finance, HR or General Affairs.
Third, Japanese firms conducting M&A abroad have begun to hire PR advisors to help. In the past, mergermarket excluded Japan from the Asia-Pacific PR advisor league tables, as the number of PR advisors supporting Japanese firms was ridiculously low.
This has changed. Of course, Japanese firms have been on the hunt overseas for some time and show no sign of letting up. New is the active positioning.
In the past, Japanese shied away from difficult deals and regularly lost in competitive bidding situations. They also gained a reputation for happily overpaying to avoid problems. This is no longer true. Japanese firms are increasingly like any other international bidders. And this means they also actively engage in their own positioning.
The implications for Western companies go way beyond the fact that they face Japanese firms better prepared for competitive bidding outside Japan. Japanese firms are also slowly starting to strategically bolster their images overseas.
Back in 2013, Japanese companies accounted for 13% of the Fortune Global Top 250 by revenue. However, only 1.6% were among the Fortune Top 250 Most Admired Companies. This share has more than doubled over the last two years.
At the same time, Japan climbed into the Top 5 of nearly nation reputation ranking. In 2015, it topped the nation brand ranking of Futurebrand for the first time. Kyoto has become the most preferred travel destination and Tokyo tops several global city rankings by Travel and Leisure, Monocle, the Economist and others.
In terms of strategic communication capabilities, Japanese firms still lag behind their Western competitors. Particularly B2B firms still often act like innocents when entering the global positioning stage, easily outclassed by their Korean and Chinese peers.
But they’re catching up. If the Prime Minster has discovered the international media as an effective tool, Japanese firms won’t be far behind. Just look how the Japanese government – hand-in-glove with its private sector – are playing the international media to secure a multi-billion order for the next generation of submarines from Australia.
Japanese companies are world-class level in many areas – from R&D to manufacturing to services. If they can get their act together and professionalise their communications, too, we in the West had better watch out.