Japan Blog

 

THE FUTURE OF MITSUBISHI MOTORS

Yes, the title of this post describes what nobody knows as of today. And this includes me. But I want to share a few clues of what it might look like it.

 

The news of Mitsubishi Motors’ fuel efficiency data falsification broke on April 20. I have not commented on this in this blog despite closely following the developments in the media. Having served as MMC’s Executive Officer and Head of Communications till 2004 and knowing  a bit of crisis management in Japan in general, few cases interest me more.

Many journalists have contacted me over the last three weeks but I have stayed silent as comments on any crisis situation can only be as good as the actual insights, which are usually limited. In this case – let me state this very clearly – I have no special insights, I have not talked to or with any involved party, and do not represent any side in this case. On Thursday finally, it turned from an ongoing crisis issue to a very interesting business development with Nissan’s announcement on Thursday to buy 34% of MMC and effectively bring it under its umbrella.

This made me finally comment on Carlos Ghosn to the Financial Times. But it is here where I would like to share my view on the big picture, i.e. the future of Mitsubishi Motors. Naturally, this means a longer post than usual. Apologies to those who only look for soundbites or a simple three-liner.

Any such prediction needs to be based on assumptions about the relevant players and their to be expected actions. Mine – in short – are as follows:
Mitsubishi Motors: Is without a properly functioning control center, which is able to pro-actively take charge of the current situation.
Mitsubishi Group: Is fed up with reputation problems stemming from MMC, is not willing to further lend capital and credibility, and will welcome any solution that increases the distance between the Group and MMC.
Nissan Motors: Is facing ongoing frictions with Renault’s major shareholder, the French government, and struggles with its bet on a fast take-off of electric vehicles, its major strategic bet of the recent years.
Carlos Ghosn: Is smart, ambitions and willing to take high risks for elevating the Nissan-Renault alliance to the top of the automotive world, i.e. the club of 10 million units per year (currently Toyata, Volkswagen and GM).
Ministry of Transport MLIT: Is annoyed by having again to deal with MMC wrongdoings and will take a tough stance on the company as long as the Japanese media and public demand it.
Japanese Media: Is the probably most decisive actor here and acts as usual. It strongly beats on the culprit MMC but is also prepared to switch towards embracing the Nissan solution to the problems at hand, in other words to turn silent soon.
Japanese Customers and Public: Have once and forever lost faith in Mitsubishi Motors to a level that is not recoverable to a meaningful extent.
Japanese auto market: Is having too many players and has been longing for consolidation for some time.

Based on above assumptions you might already guess the line of my thinking. In short, Nissan’s (or lets say Carlos Ghosn’s) decision to step up as a white knight seems to be the best solution for all involved players. It is however not a foregone conclusion yet that everything will run smooth. Just yesterday, the MLIT stepoed up its investigations by investigating the MMC headquarters for the first time and linking top officials to the wrongdoings.

But let us make a final assumption and say – what is likely – the next weeks’ revelations will not escalate out of hand and Nissan’s due diligence will lead to a closing of the announced Nissan-Mitsubishi Motors alliance. We will then see the basis for Mitsubishi Motors’ future, which will likely look similar to the following scenario.

MMC’s mini-car business, core of today’s scandal, will eventually cease to exist and be fully transferred to an exclusively Nissan-owned and branded business (and become Nissan’s biggest price for rescuing MMC).
MMC’s domestic sales of regular cars will substantially go down in numbers but will be kept on – as its continuation is needed to give the brand credibility for overseas markets such as in South East Asia.
MMC’s overseas business in those markets will remain strong with Nissan’s support and investments. It remains to be seen whether it will be sufficiently successful to justify for Nissan to keep MMC as a group company or whether the brand will be ultimately sold to a foreign competitor from China, India or elsewhere.

I do not want to bother you with too many disclaimers regarding above prediction. Ultimately, lots will depend on the diplomatic and communication skills of Carlos Ghosn during the next weeks as well as the following two to three years. If the Japanese media, read the Japanese system, turns against him and thus against MMC’s rescue, all bets will be off.

Japanese media and public opinion can kill any individual’s ambition as numerous politicians and business men had to learn the hard way in the past. If Ghosn manages to avoid such a fate, the short-term rescue of MMC and long-term blooming of Nissan are more likely to happen than not. Skillful communications to a wide number of stakeholders will be the key – and I know few top managers who are more aware of this task and who master the communication challenges better than Carlos Ghosn (who never was and probably never will be one my clients – ha, ha).

 

Author: Jochen Legewie
Published: May 14, 2016

Share

Category

Archive