It is Golden Week in Japan. For once, Tokyo is rather quiet and hotel rooms are available. But the year-long reality in Tokyo (and even more in Osaka) is a different one. Occupancy rates of hotels in Tokyo have become tighter than all other major cities (close to 90% on annual average).
Major reason is the recent tourism boom that has increased foreign visitors to Japan to 20 million last year. More so this boom will continue with a new official target of 40 million visitors from abroad by 2020. This target is absolutely realistic because the growth of visitors from Asia does not only depend on a weakened yen and the relaxing of visa requirements. The main structural reason is an increasing middle-class in Asia, which will not go away regardless of yen fluctuations or a relative downturn of the Chinese economy.
It is no wonder that the private property rental through online platforms such as Airbnb has been exploding. In 2015, Japan was Airbnb’s fastest growing market with an increase of more than 500%. Likewise, it is no wonder that problems and conflicts have arisen. The hotel industry is – despite currently enjoying a major boon – concerned about private competition and running storm against a deregulation of its industry and a promotion of the “minpaku” system, the private rental of rooms.
Another major problem is the opposition of residents living as direct neighbors to places rented out privately by Airbnb hosts and other private operators. Concerns raise from actual problems related to noise, waste handling and other normal tenant issues to a more general sentiment of suddenly having too many foreigners penetrating a hitherto closed Japanese neighborhood.
The Japanese government is fully aware of these issues. It needs to balance the need to provide sufficient hotel room for the intended surge of foreign visitors with a meaningful deregulation of a sector, protected by seven-decade old laws and vested interests. More so, it does not want to risk to alienate the Japanese people and thus its electorate with a too foreigner-friendly policy while stressing Japan’s identity and the need for constitutional reforms at the same time. It is preparing a new minpaku law for submission to the Diet in 2017. For details in English here.
Enter Berlin. Enter a new problem. Enter a new direction that the minpaku discussion in Japan will likely take. What am I talking about?
Berlin has become one of Europe’s hottest travel destinations with 30 million registered overnight stays in 2015. It is estimated that additional 6 million overnight stays took place via private online bookings. Rents in Berlin have shot up 56 percent between 2009 and 2014. Many Berliners have decided to join the lucrative market of renting out full flats to benefit from short-term visitors whose payments add up to a multiple of a regular monthly rent income.
As a result, Berlin has seen a major crowding out and people with low income are struggling to find affordable apartments. The new law no longer allows to rent out full flats or homes via portals such as Airbnb, only single rooms.
A similar development can also happen in Tokyo, Osaka or any other major Japanese city. If the minpaku system coupled with a surge of foreign visitors leads to a crowding out of low income Japanese individuals and families, we are in for trouble.
First of all, this is a major serious concern for those directly affected. But it could also be a recipe for anti-foreigner sentiments in a Japan that overall needs and benefits from more internationalization.
Prime Minister Abe might touch on this topic when meeting with German Chancellor Merkel in Berlin this week. I strongly feel that is no exaggeration saying that Berlin holds major lessons for the future course of Japan and its internationalization via foreign visitors.
Author: Jochen LegewiePublished: May 3, 2016