Japan Blog

 

DECISION TAKEN: TAX HIKE TO BE DELAYED AGAIN

No, the actual decision has not been taken yet. But the odds for another hike delay look to me extremely high as they do for anybody who knows how the Japanese system works.

 

This week was a classic example of how the Japanese government starts early in shaping public opinion and preparing it to support an upcoming decision. Since 8 days government officials have started to whisper much more than ever about the pros and cons of raising the consumption tax in April 2017 as planned.
In addition, the International Finance and Economic Assessment Council has launched a series of meetings where Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and Cabinet ministers can exchange views  on this topic with experts from Japan and abroad. The council’s meetings are obviously aimed at laying a foundation for delaying once again the tax hike as Abe has invited many scholars holding cautious views to speak at these meetings.
In the first meeting last Wednesday, Columbia University and nobel prize winner Prof. Joseph Stiglitz suggested delaying the consumption tax hike again, insisting “now is not the time to raise the rate.” On Tuesday, economist Paul Krugman will follow, a strong voice against raising taxes before deflation is overcome.
I am convinced Abe will make a decision and announcement about the tax hike – delay or not – around the G 7 Ise-Shima Summit on May 26-27. It is only natural that he wants to display leadership in presenting concrete economic remedial measures at this summit and to send a clear message aimed at Japan’s role for a sustainable, powerful growth of the global economy.
Many foreign experts will cry foul if Japan postpones the tax hike again and thus will again not deliver on fiscal consolidation. The same opinion is held by Finance Minister Taro Aso and his ministry, the most powerful domestic opponents to another hike delay.
But let us face the truth. Global leaders are concerned about the current state of the world economy. They will rather applaud a Japan announcement that aims at avoiding demand decline in Japan then come out as strict enforcers of Japan fiscal discipline.
Ultimately, it will be Abe’s decision. And he has one huge reason to favor another delay. Public opinion is against a tax rise and Abe wants to win elections and gain two-third majorities in both houses to progress with his planned constitutional revision. Unless you doubt this to be his priority 1 goal, the implications are clear:
The decision is taken, there will be no tax hike in April 2017. We are currently just watching the preparation of reasoning for this decision to be announced in late May.

 

Author: Jochen Legewie
Published: March 19, 2016

Share

Category

Archive