First Fatal Shinkansen Accident

 

Share

Last Sunday, a Yamagata shinkansen bullet train collided with a passenger car killing the driver of that car. This tragic accident is remarkable in many ways.To my knowledge, it was the first fatal accident involving a shinkansen train in the the nearly 50-year long history of Japan’s high-speed train. On the train itself, nobody was injured seriously. No other high-speed train worldwide has achieved a similar impressive safety record over the past decades.
Interestingly, Japanese media reported on the accident in a rather subdued tone. Reporting was limited and there was no reference to the shattering of the safety record. This is understandable but stands in stark contrast to the often-made safety argument when reporting on potential exports of the shinkansen technology in the past.
I personally feel that the media exercised some form of restraint by avoiding any reference to the past safety record of the shinkansen. Probably, most editors felt it would hurt Japanese national interests mentioning this fact. I think the opposite is true. Any tendency towards avoiding straight reporting results in doubts and suspicion, just think of Fukushima. The safety record of the Japanese shinkansen technology is second to none globally. This remains true even after Sunday’s accident. But avoiding the topic does not help in spreading this true and positive message.

Jochen Legewie

Jochen Legewie

More posts

Categories

Archive