Japan Blog

 

FREEDOM OF PRESS – ONE MORE PERSPECTIVE

Foreign but also domestic observers have recently decried a shrinking freedom of the press in Japan. Various acts by government officials have been interpreted as (at best) inappropriate or (even worse) outright acts of meddling with a free press for the benefit of promoting a more nationalistic policy.

 

It is not possible to properly address and evaluate this topic in a simple blog post. But I want to introduce one thought that is often missing from the debate. Interestingly, this thought was confirmed to me over the last weeks in several discussions with leading Japanese journalists whose insights and judgement I value highly.

Put simple, the idea is as follows: The current Japanese government is not meddling with the press much more than former governments. It is rather a certain form of self-censorship at most (but not all) media* that explains their stance and behavior. Media organizations expect the Abe government to stay in power at least until 2017 and do not want to mess too much with government/majority opinion before then. This is especially true as Japan currently does not have a functioning opposition. The Japanese people at large (the silent majority) are satisfied with the political status quo. Without an outcry of the political opposition or the Japanese people the government will further promote its policies and further stretch its forms of “press guidance”.

All of this happens in a Japanese set of well-organized media structures incl. press-clubs run by the mainstream media themselves. The latter one itself is a violation of freedom of press by Western views but not by the majority Japanese view.

I am neither taking a side here nor am I offering any answer. We are rather facing a chicken and egg issue here. By Western standards the case is simple: If civil society and democracy don’t work there will be no free press and without a free press society and democracy are endangered.

But is this really the case in Japan? There are two big issues that might offer an answer to that question.
I assume that a “silent” majority agrees to restart nuclear power stations and I expect this to happen, though slowly, over the next years.
I also assume that a “silent” majority is opposed to Abe’s wishes for revising the constitution and I expect him to be eventually fail in a fundamental revision as envisaged today.

And – what is important here – in both cases the Japanese media will likely play a decisive role within its terms of freedom of press, whether we foreigners like and accept it or not.

Note: An interesting and remarkable exception is Tokyo Shimbun taking a distinctive anti-Abe stance, which seems to have been economically rewarded by a recent surge in subscriptions and readers.

Author: Jochen Legewie
Published: June 14, 2015

Share

Category

Archive