On Saturday, history was made in Japan. For the first time, a foreign company outrightly took over an industrial icon - a step which will hopefully turn out to be a milestone for an opening up of Japan Inc. with overall positive effects.
Yes, Renault has bought 44% of Nissan but not the majority. Yes, Daimler owns more than 90% of Mitsubishi Fuso Truck & Bus Corporation. But only as a spin-off from Mitsubishi Motors, which ultimately remained Japanese. Yes, Haier bought the white good business from Panasonic but not the company or brand itself. All of these investments turned out positively. But they are different from this case.
No automotive, electronic or machinery company in Japan has ever been fully “taken over” by a foreign one. Sharp is a household brand name and without doubt an industrial icon. Hence this step is remarkable. It took several years and many twists and turns to conclude with the INCJ, a Japanese government-backed corporate rehabilitation fund, offering an alternative “Japanese” solution to Sharp, its banks and shareholders.
Domestic and foreign observers have commented in detail on this process – and so did I here in this blog. Hence I do not want to repeat this here. But it is interesting to note that until the very end, the majority of Japanese media had reported rather negatively about Hon Hai and its Chairman Gou and a perceived “unfair” treatment of Sharp during the negotiations.
Only few have realized that global standards and best practice have been meeting Japanese inertia and a strong emotional opposition to foreign ownership. The fact that Hon Hai is from Taiwan and thus perceived to be half Chinese did and does not help here.
Two days ago, I was invited to speak on a new Nikkei live TV program called Nikkei TV Saturday 9. I clearly stated that this take-over is good news for a Japanese economy that needs to open up also in terms of foreign ownership to prevail in Asian and global competition. The co-commentator, an economics professor of Tokyo University, mirrored my statement and stressed among others the benefits of fast decision-making that Hon Hai will bring to Sharp and Japan.
I cross my fingers that this historic investment will turn out positively and thus pave the way for a more open attitude in Japan towards restructuring and investment from abroad. Japan needs such an attitude, and it has to start with the media shaping opinion here.