NUCLEAR POWER HERE TO STAY
As of today the Sendai nuclear power plant in Kyushu is again generating electricity after restarting operations last Tuesday morning.
As of today the Sendai nuclear power plant in Kyushu is again generating electricity after restarting operations last Tuesday morning.
A clear prediction of the long-term use of nuclear energy in Japan is difficult, but the direction is obvious. The government has succeeded in making its use acceptable again to the Japanese people. This is despite a growing opposition since the Fukushima disaster and many polls showing a majority of Japanese preferring a nuclear-free future.
However, this opposition is not well organized and still lacking a major political party to unify it and give it political weight – and this is unlikely to change in the near future. Hence, the outlook for reactivating further reactors is good. Sendai facility’s No. 2 reactor will likely follow this autumn and reactor No. 3 at the Ikata plant in Shikoku around winter.
Five out of Japan’s 43 operable nuclear reactors have so far passed the main layer of scrutiny by nuclear reactors. Most observers agree that the new safety standards of the Nuclear Regulation Authority are the strictest in the world. Besides, there are other good arguments speaking in favor of reintroducing nuclear power generation to Japan.
Two weeks ago, visiting economist Jeffrey Sachs argued that Japan depends on nuclear power as the only means to get anywhere close to achieving its CO2 emission reduction goals. From the viewpoint of energy security, today’s reliance on imported fuels accounting for 90% of total power supply is problematic. Finally, also the rise of the energy prices has to be taken into account. Home electricity costs have gone up by 25% compared to pre-Fukushima levels, electricity bills for industrial use even by 38%.
It is against this background that the current energy policy – approved by the METI last month – calls for nuclear to account for as much as 22% of Japan’s electricity by 2030. The same program predicts renewables to account for up to 24%. This slightly higher figure provides a politically valuable feel-good-value, but is also ambitious in a country with less of 10% of renewable energies today.
So what exactly is the outlook for the next ten years? I don’t see any new nuclear reactors to be approved in the future. Instead, we will see a few more existing reactors getting back online, many of which will soon get to the 40-years lifetime after which they should be decommissioned according to existing guidelines. Proponents of nuclear energy are already urging the government to adopt a policy of extending the operating lifetime of reactors to up to 60 years.
But I can’t see Japan getting anywhere close to the above mentioned level 0f 22%. In many regions, local opposition is much stronger than in Kyushu and it will be difficult for the government and power companies to overcome it easily. Nevertheless, as of now there is a silent majority that approves the current government line.
There is however one scenario that might turn the tide and really stir up opposition in a way that will also be felt in political circles on a decision-making level. There is a strong majority in Japan worrying about Prime Minister Abe’s direction with regard to security policies and a potential revision of Japan’s constitution.
If the anti-nuclear movement will unite with those opposed to the defense legislation, all bets for a strong nuclear revival are off. As of today, the odds are yet not very high. But the recent significant slide in the government’s approval rates shows a very tangible risk for Mr. Abe – and thus also for the nuclear industry in Japan.