Japanese Semiconductor Industry – Quo Vadis?
Japanese chip makers once dominated the world market. Now their future looks less secure than ever.
Japanese chip makers once dominated the world market. Now their future looks less secure than ever.
“Sangyo no kome” – this is what the semiconductor industry was once called in Japan. Literally meaning “rice of the industry” this expression was first used for the steel industry as the core basis of Japanese industrial development. Later, the term was applied to the semiconductor industry. And indeed, Japanese firms once dominated the industry occupying more than 50% of the global market and being at the core of the electronics industry.
These times are long gone. There are only three Japanese firms left in the global Top 20, Toshiba (7), Renesas (14) and Sony (16). All of them face there own problems with Toshiba undergoing massive restructuring following an accounting scandal and Renesas under permanent reform led by state-fund INCJ but with no clear growth strategy, no industrial core shareholder and no global technology partner.
At the same time, industrial eyes are back at an industry that provides the core of innovations for other main sectors beyond the electronics sectors, namely the automotive industry and other industrial applications, especially in the energy sector.
A major consolidation wave has started and will again reshape the global set-up of this industry. Economies of scale, need for huge R&D investments, easily available cheap capital and other factors are driving this global consolidation trend. The newest and biggest factor however might be China. Yesterday, the Economist pointed out how aggressive Chinese with massive government backing firms are investing into this industry. A new national plan has earmarked up to USD 150 billion for public and private funds.
China is spending more on semiconductor imports than for its imported oil. China accounts for more than 40% of global semiconductor turnover. So guess whether Chinese ambitions in this area are serious or not.
So where does this leave Japan and its domestic semiconductor firms? So far not in a sweet spot. They need to grow in size by themselves via acquisitions or via intelligent global alliances to allow them to stay in the technology game. Focus on certain areas of expertise and operating at a global scale is no longer an option but a must.
Japanese as well as European and US chipmakers must stay ahead of their Chinese competitors in terms of technology and innovation capacity to survive. If you want to serve the automotive industry for example, it is them to drive the innovations allowing autonomous driving and other new trends, not the automakers themselves.
If Renesas & Co. do not get their act (i.g. global business strategy) together quickly, they will vanish over time regardless how much support the Japanese government is willing to offer. Competitors might sit in Europe, the U.S. or Korea. But the real enemy is emerging in China. And it will be the customers of Japanese chipmakers such as Japanese automakers that will suffer from such a development the most.
I have never been a friend any form of protection. But if – and only if – I had to agree to one, it would be for Japanese rice. But over-protecting semiconductors as “rice of the industry” is simply a mistake that Japan should not commit and simply cannot afford.