Share
- June 20, 2015
- Japan
June is when most Japanese companies hold their shareholder meetings. Does 2015 bring winds of change as hoped for by many foreign shareholders for a long time now? The answer is a clear “yes and no”.
In fiscal 2014, foreign ownership of 3,565 major Japanese companies rose to a record high 32 percent, growing for a third year in a row. This development did not only happen as a result of well-founded expectations for boosted earnings helped by a weaker yen.
It also reflects the expectations for higher dividend payments driven by more vocal shareholders incl. activist shareholders such as Third Point. Many observers point to the doubling of Fanuc’s dividend payout as a clear proof point for the influence that its shareholder Third Point is already having in the background.
On June 1, Japan changed its corporate governance code based on the strong political will for reforming the operation model of many Japanese firms. It is no longer naïve to expect higher shareholder payouts by Japan Inc. over the next years. I was personally stunned by a statement of Marubeni Chairman Asada to a group of Japanese company CEOs two weeks ago. “A company that does not achieve an average ROE of 5 percent or more should not be allowed to have a license to operate.”
So, Japan will follow in the footsteps of the U.S. and the U.K.? Unfortunately, the answer is not that simple. Yes, Japanese firms will strengthen corporate governance and will also have higher shareholder payouts. But Japan will also go its own way as it always has done.
Just look at the new class of stock that Toyota’s shareholders approved for the firm last Tuesday. This new class of stock is highly controversial as it will be unlisted, must be held for a minimum of five years and is only readily available in Japan. Toyota is aiming for increasing the share of long-term oriented retail investors.
It argues that its business requires long-term product planning and thus will benefit from increasing this investor type (individual investors currently account for only 10.5 percent of its shares, much lower than the 20 percent average for listed Japanese firms). Funds like the California State Teachers’ Retirement System have complained and recommended a ‘no’ vote at Tuesday’s shareholder meeting. Others like proxy adviser Glass, Lewis & Co. have praised it.
This small episode underlines my claims made above. Japan is changing but it does it in its own way. Those wishing to benefit from the upcoming corporate changes in Japan are well advised to base their expectations and actions on a thorough analysis and case-by-case evaluation.