Japan Blog

 

YOMIURI ATTEMPTS TO BALANCE WWII STATEMENT

The world (at least the U.S, China and Kora) will closely watch Prime Minister Abe's address to a joint session of the U.S. Congress today as he will be the first Japanese to do so in history. It is interesting to see that back at home the conservative and LDP-friendly Yomiuri newspaper has recently issued various comments that warn Abe not to appear too self-righteous, in particular when addressing Japan's role in the world in the past, present and future.

 

Japan’s dealing with its war past is known as  a long route with many twist and turns. Hence please allow me to address this issue today in a post that is longer than usual. Japanese leaders have made many sincere statements addressing the country’s war past and responsibility. But Japan as a country never fully succeeded in convincing the world of a fundamental acceptance of its war responsibility as for example  Germany managed to do. This was – among others factors – due to a lack of communication skills by its actors but also due to relentless efforts of the Korean and Chinese governments to exploit the Japanese war past for their own national benefit. It is against this background that recent editorials and outside expert comments printed in the Yomiuri Shimbun draw my attention. In its 22 April editorial, the Yomiuri stated ‘it is impossible to comprehensively review the 70 years with a historical perception that starts from the point where post-war Japan admitted the aggression was wrong’. The Yomiuri warns again omitting the word “aggression” in Abe’s upcoming WWII statement on August 15 and goes on saying ‘The statement of the 70th anniversary is no longer that of the prime minister alone. It has been accepted in Japan and abroad as a statement to represent the stance of the entire nation.’ Japan and Abe are riding on a wave of recent economic success that makes Abe’s words “Japan is back” more than a slogan. There is indeed a major positive perception shift vs. Japan as not seen over the last 25 years. Abe is right to be proud on this achievement but it has to be seen in a wider global context. This is why the Yomiuri editorial goes on and warns ‘politics should not be a product of self-satisfaction’. Interestingly, a column by political scientist Shigeki Uno in the May 2015 issue of Chuo Koron makes similar observations and warnings. Chuo Koron is highly respected monthly magazine issued by the Yomiuri group and rather known for conservative views. On the same topic of the upcoming WWII statement, Uno writes that ‘the statements of a country’s prime minister are like public declarations of a commitment to that country’s historical and world views. Things that have been declared and promised once cannot be arbitrarily discarded or changed.’ Uno postulates that ‘we need to think carefully and deeply about Japan in the context of the world…and must not forget that self-righteousness and narrow-mindedness are our greatest enemies.’ I wrote on the same topic back in July 2013 in the Japan Times and have again discussed it with several business persons at a major event of Keizai Doyukai this Monday. Many told me in private that they share Yomiuri’s concern of a too self-righteous positioning of Japan in the world with regard to its war past. Perception creates reality, you might even say on many occasions ‘perception is reality’. It will be interesting to see how Abe will shape global perceptions later today in the U.S. and even more so on August 15 when the  eyes and ears will be on him as the strongest representative Japan had for many years. So far, his advisors have overall done a remarkable job in positioning Abe, Abenomics and Japan in the eyes of the world. Let’s hope together with the Yomiuri that the Prime Minister still listens to them so they will continue to do so.

Author: Jochen Legewie
Published: April 29, 2015

Share

Category

Archive