By Sophie Broom
Robert Peston’s tweet yesterday morning, just before the Chancellor stood up to give his Budget, was intriguing:
“There is a surprise in this budget that Chancellor expects to generate headlines”.
But which surprise did he mean? The introduction of a tax on sugary drinks? The reduction in corporation tax and business rates? Tax cuts to stem the decline of North Sea oil and gas? Evidently there was a lot to choose from.
For most people, it would seem that the sugar tax was the headline-grabber, but for us the biggest ‘surprise’ is the introduction of the Lifetime ISA, or LISA, as it has swiftly been dubbed by the press. Take a quick look at Twitter and you will see those who will benefit from its creation seem broadly pleased by the idea of a savings vehicle that will be subject to little tax and will see the government giving savers a pound for every four they put away. But pensions providers, consultants and industry experts have been swift to point out the potential pitfalls with the system.
It seems likely that the LISA has the potential to cause a bit of an upset in the industry. While a week or so before the Budget the Treasury put out a quiet line that no changes to pensions were to be expected (leading the industry to breathe a premature sigh of relief), it seems that the Chancellor decided to press on with a version of his least unpopular propositions – the pensions ISA. But rather than face the ridicule of the press for undermining the still-fresh auto-enrolment system, and the introduction of Pensions Freedom and Choice, Osborne has effectively introduced a dual system of savings. He has left pensions as they are, but added, for some, the option to access this new savings product.
Yes, the LISA appears more flexible than a traditional pension – it is intended not just for retirement savings, but for deposits on homes, or large family purchases. But essentially it works in the same way as a pension product: a vehicle for consumers to put aside money for their future prosperity.
The ultimate win for the Treasury with the LISA is that, unlike a pension, where the money you save remains untaxed until you withdraw it in retirement, this ISA, while incentivised (the government will contribute a pound for every four you put in), is taxed upfront. This releases a huge amount of tax income for the Treasury, that they would otherwise have had to wait 20 years to receive. This upfront boost for the government’s coffers will be useful in the short-term, and should allow Osborne to fulfil some of the commitments he made yesterday such as reducing fee burdens on small businesses. But it may cause problems for Chancellors to come as they look for income that has largely already been spent. Not so much ‘fixing the roof while the sun is shining’ as propping up the roof until its someone else’s responsibility.
Nevertheless, if the LISA does what it says on the tin: offering under-40s an incentivised, flexible savings route, it could be hugely beneficial for young people, as well as those starting families or buying homes. If companies are nimble and react quickly – they can use this positive feeling towards the LISA to their advantage. An increasing concern among recruiters is how to engage millennials, and what benefits to offer to attract the best graduates. If companies can mobilise themselves quickly, and offer contributions to LISAs as part of their employment packages, highlighting the benefits of saving with flexibility to access their cash if needed, they will be able to capture the attention of a generation that wants long-term risk protection, but doesn’t want to plan long-term.
All in all it was a busy budget – after a jam-packed Autumn Statement, a bumper year of Budgets in 2015, and a looming Brexit vote – many expected that the Chancellor would keep his head below the parapet and stick to the usual rigmarole of carefully-worded OBR statistics and a few pennies off a pint. With close to 80 legislative measures announced, it was not a quiet day for hacks, flacks and bookies.
But we will be most intrigued to see how the pensions industry responds to the LISA. Not in the next few days, but in coming weeks and months. As they begin to craft new products, set up new platforms for advice, and work out whether a dual system will work well for a country divided between ‘baby boomers’ and ‘millennials’ or whether we will end up deconstructing the culture of pension saving in the UK. Let’s hope for the former.