By Nick Bastin
Financing of the move to a lower carbon world and the potential for compensation continued to be the roadblock over the weekend, this time as nations disputed the wording of a draft proposal. Under the proposed wording, developing nations, such as China and India, would be included with developed nations to meet this cost. Developing nations see this as a future threat that could force them to pay in line with the EU and US. Susheel Kumar a senior environment official in India claimed “The language is not in line with the framework convention, it is trying to redraft the convention.” On the other hand, Todd Stern of the US committee highlighted, “There are developing countries moving to being donors, this recognises that there are more advanced developing countries.” While India’s Modi described it as “morally wrong” for developed nations to avoid compensating the worst suffers, such as Bangladesh.
Over the weekend, small nations continued to push for greater change, asking for the +2C target to be lowered to +1.5C. The foreign minister of the Marshall Islands, Tony de Brum, told Paris on Saturday, “I refuse to go home to my people without a Paris agreement that allows me to look them in the eye and say that everything is going to be OK.” It seems unlikely that developed and developing nations will agree to this. However, Miguel Arias Cañete, EU climate commissioner, told the Financial Times there was a “growing understanding” that loss and damage provisions would be included in the Paris agreement, as long as they did not expose wealthy countries to new claims for compensation.
Richard Branson’s B Team group of executives have called for Paris to embrace the ‘carbon neutral by 2050’ goal, and not to dismiss the idea of limiting warming to 1.5C. Mary Robinson, former Irish president and head of the Foundation for Climate, said “We have a commitment to stay below 2 degrees and keep open the prospect of 1.5C.” Earlier in the year, 59 global firms, including CNC’s parent company Publicis Groupe, signed an agreement asking for carbon pricing to feature in the Paris agreement.
Nicaragua became the first nation to say it doesn’t intend to publish a national plan to prevent global warming. The nations lead negotiator Paul Oquist, described publishing the plan as a “path to failure”. Nicaragua is one of nine countries yet to submit a climate pledge. Other countries yet to sign are North Korea, Libya, East Timor, Nepal, Uzbekistan, St Kitts and Nevis and Panama.
Despite these issues, a draft negotiation text was signed by all delegates on Saturday. Ministers now have five days to ensure the text becomes a deal accepted by all 195 parties. The current document has more than 900 square brackets that are in place to highlight areas of disagreement. Talks are far from finished, as Miguel Arias Canet, the European Union’s Climate Commissioner, claimed “All the difficult political issues remain unsolved, and will be solved by the ministers.”
Ban Ki Moon opened the final week of talks on Monday telling delegates “The world is expecting more from you than half-measures and incremental approaches,”
Monday saw the beginning of key government officials, such as John Kerry, arrive in Paris, in an effort to conclude a deal. India are continuing their strong stance from week one. As Shri Prakash Javadekar, India’s Minister for Environment, Forests and Climate Change, said the real cost of the global energy transformation will amount to trillions, however the $100 billion from developed nations was “a symbolic but important gesture and one should not run away from it”.
The Financial Times reported on Monday that global emissions had possibly stalled or even fallen according to a group of scientists. The scientists believe levels may have fallen by 0.6% in 2015. “These figures are certainly not typical,” according to Professor Corinne Le Quéré of the UK’s University of East Anglia. The fall is attributed to China’s reduction in their use of coal and the EU and US reduced emission levels.
On Monday evening, The Independent reported that official EU documents had been leaked, revealing that EU governments had instructed their representatives to block discussion of two key mechanisms that could help combat the effects of global warming: the introduction of measures to curb the negative environmental impacts of global trade, and the transfer of technology to help poorer countries in their fight against climate change.
Activists ‘Climate Criminals’ made an appearance on Monday, posting over a 1,000 “Wanted” posters outside top Parisian hotels overnight. The posters called out seven people linked to the fossil fuel industry or those who are sceptics of climate change. The seven people included Benjamin Sporton, chief executive of the World Coal Association and Fiona Wild vice president of BHP Billiton.
Reuters has highlighted how clean energy solutions are yet to gain major attention at in Paris as the talks enter their final few days. Edward Guinness, portfolio manager at the Guinness Atkinson Alternative Energy Fund, said he has “low expectations