For the fund management industry, 2013 will be remembered as a year of major change, with some of the UK’s best known names jumping ship, retiring or setting up shop on their own.
For fund management firms, these moves represent not only a recruitment headache but a major reputational risk, as firms seek to replace the seemingly irreplaceable, while crucially retaining assets.
In its recent Lombard column, the FT laid the responsibility squarely at the door of investment companies for any damage to their business caused by star manager exits. But in its defence, the industry is only really guilty of responding to the cult of celebrity created by intermediaries and the media, which has helped them humanise funds and their investment processes.
In fact, one look at the relatively low AUMs in passive or systematic strategies, which have no key man risk, compared to active strategies, suggests that the UK investor psyche is governed by a need to be able to stare into the whites of the person’s eyes running your money, even if it is via Investment Week.
So investment managers are in fact caught in a paradoxical situation. If they fail to promote their managers and build their profiles, they could struggle to attract inflows. On the flipside, recent events show how easy it is to become a victim of your own success, particularly when a name that is synonymous with your brand heads for the door.
The UK market’s reaction to the impact of fund manager departures ignores some fundamental facts. Even the brightest stars in the mutual fund world are supported by robust teams of talented individuals who generate and test investment ideas on a continual basis. In addition, track records are fickle and while managers take goodwill with them, it can take time to build real conviction in their ability to replicate performance in a new environment.
Many firms have also gone to great lengths to emphasise their team based approach to running funds, but this is an industry pre-disposed to attribute responsibility to an individual. Any ratings agency or fund factsheet still requires a fund manager name to be recorded and the investment trade media thrive on the views of the big stars.
The coverage in recent weeks has served as a warning shot for any firm that isn’t succession planning for its biggest names and effective communications lies at the heart of this process. For many firms, coordinating the way that this information is shared with key stakeholder groups remains the real challenge, particular in a sector that is prone to leaks.
Even with contingency plans firmly set in place, star manager moves raise the more fundamental question of whether the investment industry should be building star funds, not star managers.