Resist the lure of the lie

 

Share

Post-truth communications is one political technique that business must reject

During the UK’s recent EU referendum campaign, Michael Gove declined the opportunity to name a single economist who backed Brexit, famously saying that “people have had enough of experts.”  As it turned out, he was right.  Whether assertions about the catastrophic consequences of Turkey’s ‘imminent’ arrival in the EU, or that EU membership cost Britain £350m per week, Britain ultimately backed a campaign based more on emotional resonance than truth.

The same public response may well decide the current US Presidential campaign.  The non-partisan fact checking service, Politifact, recently rated 158 of Donald Trump’s assertions and labelled 95 of them as ‘False’ or, even more damning, ‘Pants on Fire’.  And yet Trump’s brazen disregard for the truth has fought off numerous rivals for the Republican ticket and may yet win him the White House.

The Economist highlighted this growing phenomena of ‘post-truth’ politics – the reliance on assertions that ‘feel true’ but have no basis in fact – in a recent front page editorial.  “Feelings, not facts, are what matter in this sort of campaigning” it stated, and rightly called the trend “worrying.” However even more worrying would be if the corporate world, with its long track record of borrowing from the political communications playbook, began to adopt these darker arts.  Business must resist that temptation.

Far-fetched?  Consider first the frequency with which communications tactics hatched in political campaigning become mainstream in corporate communications.   The now widespread use of audience research, of data and analytical tools, and of integrated campaigning, all began in the political arena.  There is a well-trodden path of political advisors now plying their trade in the world of business, armed with the very same techniques that made them successful in politics in the first place.

Second, the media environment that has allowed ‘post-truth’ campaigning to prosper is just as relevant to the world of business as it is to politics.  Traditional journalism still plays a valuable role in holding politicians and business people to account, but that role is diminishing.  The incredible growth in social media has created networks of people who trust each other more than any established media outlet, meaning that mistruths can quickly take on the appearance of fact.  The consequence is an environment in which politicians, or business leaders, can begin to feel less accountable to the truth.  An environment which in time can give rise to communications techniques more often associated with authoritarian regimes.

Consider also some of the corporate communications trends that have gained momentum in recent years. Companies are increasingly acting as publishers, becoming sophisticated media operations in their own right, telling their story exactly how and when they want it told.  Organisations can now identify their audience precisely, target them more accurately with relevant content and encourage them to share that content within their network of like-minded people.  Search companies have become the most powerful media organisations for the very reason that they allow companies to prioritise their own curated content over more independently minded, or critical, media outlets.  WPP, the largest marketing company in the world, is projected to spend more than twice as much money with google this year than any other media organisation – more than $5bn.  The fact is, companies have never had a more effective set of tools with which to manipulate truth – should they choose to do so.

Organisations must resist the temptation to lie.  The adoption of ‘post-truth’ techniques would be an unwelcome toxin for the business community that despite declining trust is still more transparent and responsible than it was a decade ago.  It may not always appear this way to a CEO in the midst of a reputational crisis, but over the long term stakeholders will reward responsible corporate behaviour. Lying for short term gain will always, ultimately, be flawed. That places great responsibility on Boards, executive teams and communicators to ensure that communication is always grounded in fact – however tempting the alternative.

Richard Campbell

Richard Campbell

More posts

Categories