News & Views

 

The Day After Tomorrow: Perspectives on a post-Brexit Britain

 

Last night, CNC held an event in the heart of the City of London that dared to ask the thorniest of questions. What will the world look like if the UK chooses to leave the European Union on 23rd June? Would it be better off? Would the rest of Europe be worse off? Would it care? And would we see the Prime Minister fall – or even the breakup of the United Kingdom?

To create a lively discussion, CNC assembled a panel of guests from European politics, media and finance, ably facilitated by our host Darren McCaffrey, Sky News’s Political Correspondent. Representing the world of European politics was Göran Persson, former Prime Minister of Sweden. From the media we had Daniel Schaefer, Handelsblatt’s finance editor in Frankfurt. Representing the City was Mark Burgess, Chief Investment Officer of Columbia Threadneedle.

The first big question was: what sort of deal would a post-Brexit UK strike to continue trading with the EU. The consensus? Not a very good one. The panel agreed that negotiations would be long and painful, unless the UK went for the Norway model, which is unlikely to prove appealing. The Germans would likely make it tough for the UK. For one, they would not want to set a precedent. And they would want to ensure the supremacy of Frankfurt as a centre for European banking, and would thus be unlikely to allow passporting rights. A voice from the crowd argued that perhaps there were advantages in escaping the burden of EU regulation. Given that the EU has a number of structural problems, another attendee suggested the UK could have “first mover” advantage in leaving now.

The panellists shared the sentiment that the EU is in need of reform but argued that the UK, which will soon have the highest population in the EU, was best placed to drive these changes forward – in alliance with other Northern European powers like France and Germany. These successful nations need to be more active in shaping the nature of the EU going forward.

This brought the debate on to the subject of the single currency and its future, post-Brexit. Some argued that the survival of the Euro is crucial to the EU project and that it would be “disastrous” for rich nations like Germany if it were to collapse. Some even advocated greater fiscal integration within the Eurozone, encouraging the German public to accept the cost of protecting the Euro in these challenging times.

All agreed that one of the chief issues in the UK – and indeed all member states – is that nobody really understands what happens at an EU level. Immigration is a “problem” the EU is often blamed for. But as one panellist argued, the majority of EU migrants are actually highly productive. Another panellist added that immigration is necessary, given northern Europe’s declining birth rates. The issue of Germany’s open door policy was discussed in this context, with the case being put that the response was chaotic because the Germans failed to properly address the issue and the emotions behind it.

But what about the impact on UK politics? The panel was in agreement that David Cameron would probably have to resign if the vote is lost. This view was supported by an audience vote, suggesting he would lose credibility not just in the UK but also internationally. The question of Scotland’s right to another referendum was also debated, given the likelihood that the Scots will vote to remain. Contributions from our Scottish guests were mixed – with one arguing the 2014 referendum had settled the matter and another arguing that there should be a further vote, post-Brexit.

The discussion ended with thoughts on what Brexit would mean for the rest of the member states and why the UK should stay – which was the view of our panel. It was argued that the short-term impact for the EU would be higher costs, trade barriers and uncertainty in the banking and currency sectors. Long term, however, it was argued that the UK would lose out in access to its key trading partners and that Europe would miss the international influence that Britain still has. One guest argued that this was perhaps a reason why Britain could do without membership.

In true democratic style, the event concluded with a secret vote from our guests on whether they felt Britain should remain within the EU or go it alone. The result? 78% believed the UK should remain. Perhaps they had been swayed by the panel. Perhaps we had found the Europhiles of the City. Or perhaps those who work at international businesses in the heart of London see this leap into the unknown as a risk too far.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Category